The Administrative Court of the Superior Court of Justice of Madrid has issued the Judgment dismissing in full the appeal filed by a commercial entity with interests in the south of Gran Canaria against a resolution of the Regional Economic-Administrative Court of Madrid (TEARM) after Covid 19.
The litigation, with an amount set at 28.894,41 euros, addressed the claim of the appellant to rectify her self-assessments of the Corporate Income Tax corresponding to the years 2017, 2018 and 2019 in order to deduct VAT quotas that had previously been rejected in limited verification procedures.
However, the ruling expressly includes the regulations and technical rules established for the general indirect scope, noting that the rules on non-deductible input VAT and output VAT are fully applicable, where appropriate, to the Canary Islands General Indirect Tax (IGIC) and any other indirect tax paid on the acquisition of assets or services that is not directly recoverable from the Public Treasury
During the VAT tax management procedures, the State Tax Administration Agency ruled out the deduction of said fees upon finding that the entity had not proven the actual exercise of business activity nor the allocation of expenses to a taxable activity, also lacking salaried personnel and an affected premises, despite being registered in section 831.1 of the IAE relating to the purchase and sale of securities.
The taxpayer intended to automatically apply the criterion that non-deductible VAT is integrated as a higher deductible acquisition price in Corporate Income Tax in accordance with the General Accounting Plan and the binding consultation V1066-19.
The court bases its ruling on the fact that, although non-deductible input VAT is considered part of the acquisition price of assets or services, the Corporate Income Tax regulations strictly require that expenses be correlated with income, comply with the accounting registration principle and are supported by reliable evidentiary justification.
The ruling reiterates that the burden of proof rests exclusively with the taxpayer seeking to claim the tax benefit, and that the mere existence of invoices is insufficient if the actual provision of the service and its direct connection to the economic activity are not demonstrated. Since the plaintiff failed to prove the necessary conditions in court, this evidentiary deficiency directly prejudices them, thus upholding the legality of the challenged administrative acts.
Finally, the ruling orders the plaintiff to pay costs pursuant to Article 139.1 of the Law of Contentious-Administrative Jurisdiction, limiting the maximum amount to 3.000 euros in consideration of the complexity of the litigation, and opens the way for filing an appeal before the Supreme Court.











